Best Innerspring Mattress 2020 – Buyer’s Guide

The innerspring mattress is one of the oldest types of mattresses that have received a modern revival, making them popular still today.

With the unique design of coils built into the middle of the mattress and additional layers of foam and cushioning, they offer so many benefits that others don’t, including full-body support, cooling and airflow, and varying levels of firmness.

Winner
Good Morning Brunswick Spring Mattress
Linenspa 6-Inch Innerspring Mattress - Twin
Twin XL Mattress, Inofia Responsive Memory Foam Mattress, Hybrid Innerspring Mattress in a Box, Sleep Cooler with More Pressure Relief & Support, CertiPUR-US Certified, 10 Inch, Twin XL
Olee Sleep 10 Inch Milky Way Tight Top Hybrid Spring Mattress, Full, White
Zinus Ultima Comfort 8 Inch Spring Mattress, Full
Our Rating
9.6
9.2
9.0
8.7
8.5
MSRP
$219.99
$74.99
Price not available
$191.05
$199.98
Size
Various
75″ x 39″ x 6”
80″ x 39″ x 12”
75″ x 54″ x 10”
75″ x 54″ x 8”
Material
Foam
Polyester and foam
Memory foam
Foam and poly jacquard
Foam
Type
Various
Twin
Twin XL
Full
Full
Warranty
15 years
10 years
10 years
10 years
10 years
Winner
Good Morning Brunswick Spring Mattress
Our Rating
9.6
MSRP
$219.99
Size
Various
Material
Foam
Type
Various
Warranty
15 years
More Information
Linenspa 6-Inch Innerspring Mattress - Twin
Our Rating
9.2
MSRP
$74.99
Size
75″ x 39″ x 6”
Material
Polyester and foam
Type
Twin
Warranty
10 years
More Information
Twin XL Mattress, Inofia Responsive Memory Foam Mattress, Hybrid Innerspring Mattress in a Box, Sleep Cooler with More Pressure Relief & Support, CertiPUR-US Certified, 10 Inch, Twin XL
Our Rating
9.0
MSRP
Price not available
Size
80″ x 39″ x 12”
Material
Memory foam
Type
Twin XL
Warranty
10 years
More Information
Olee Sleep 10 Inch Milky Way Tight Top Hybrid Spring Mattress, Full, White
Our Rating
8.7
MSRP
$191.05
Size
75″ x 54″ x 10”
Material
Foam and poly jacquard
Type
Full
Warranty
10 years
More Information
Zinus Ultima Comfort 8 Inch Spring Mattress, Full
Our Rating
8.5
MSRP
$199.98
Size
75″ x 54″ x 8”
Material
Foam
Type
Full
Warranty
10 years
More Information

When you’re in the market for a new mattress it can be overwhelming to start looking, due to the hundreds of options out there.

If it’s time for you to upgrade your mattress of you just want to see what all the fuss is about, we’ve rounded up the best innerspring mattress options to help you out.

Our top picks cover all budgets and features so you’ll be able to get the exact mattress to suit your sleep style.

A quality innerspring mattress will last many years so it’s an investment you want to take seriously, but one that doesn’t have to cost a fortune just to get something well-made and supportive.

This buying guide will walk you through our top innerspring mattress reviews and show you what to look for in terms of coil sizes, gauges, shapes, additional layers, and designs.

With our help, you’ll make an important purchase that will give you full body support and comfort like you never imagined, and all with the simple switch of a brand new innerspring mattress.

The best spring mattress might look different to everyone, but there are some brands out there that know how to choose the right features and package them for the right price.

Regardless of how many springs you want or the firmness you prefer for a mattress, these are our recommendations for the best on the market as well as what makes them so special.

Winner: Good Morning Brunswick Spring Mattress

goodmorning brunswick

 

Good Morning is a Canadian mattress brand known for making affordable and practical sleep solutions, and their Brunswick Spring Mattress is no exception to their reputation.

This is our favorite choice for an innerspring mattress that also uses the best parts of cushioning memory foam, and it ranges in options from twin to California King.

The Brunswick offers advanced lumbar support and is well within everyone’s price range, so it’s no surprise that it’s one of Good Morning’s best sellers.

What customers loved most about this mattress was everything that’s included for the price. It has 12 inches of thickness and five different layers, all working hard to give you the most comfortable sleep you’ve ever experienced.

As a spring hybrid you get the best of both worlds with foam and individually encased springs so it works for sleepers who prefer either option. You’ll benefit from a triple strength knit cover that protects everything inside and helps keep it all together to last for the full 10-year warranty.

If you’ve chosen an innerspring mattress with the hopes that it’ll stop you from feeling your partner moving around, you’re in luck. The zoned pocketed steel springs of the Brunswick were designed to isolate movement which means you won’t feel a thing.

With the additional thicker springs located in the center it also offers good lumbar support for all sleepers who share the bed. Even heavier sleepers will get quality support from this mattress and it’s capable of comfortably holding two people with a combined weight of 500lbs without putting it through any strain.

Rated a medium-firm by Good Morning, most customers found that it was far firmer than this. It offers great lumbar support and takes the pressure off where it needs to, but if you’re a lighter sleeper or after something plush, you might even find it uncomfortable.

The addition of a mattress topper could add some plushness to the top layer if you still want to benefit from all of the good stuff that the Brunswick Spring Mattress has to offer, but then again it could be easier to just buy a mattress that’s your preferred level of softness.

Other noteworthy features include the multiple layers of foam that go into making this mattress. You’ll be sleeping on Euro-top cushion fill, cooling gel memory foam, tri-zone eco foam, and edge support encasement foam.

Unlike other bed-in-a-box products, this one expands nicely while still keeping its shape. The heavier weight is thanks to its thick steel springs and edge support foam, so they’re nice touches that make it feel like a much more expensive mattress than it actually is.

Good Morning makes a range of other sleep products to go with the Brunswick mattress including memory foam pillows and bed bases built to suit the exact measurements.

Your new mattress works on most types of bed bases, and even adjustable beds, which is another huge bonus of choosing a hybrid innerspring mattress.

As a Canadian brand, they offer free shipping to those in the country and a small fee for US residents, but because they’re priced so well it’s still a bargain even with these extra charges.

To experience what an affordable and supportive sleep feels like on our favorite innerspring mattress, it has to be the Good Morning Brunswick Spring Mattress.

You can get this budget-friendly mattress for around $530 for a Queen or roughly $650 for the California King, making it well priced by anyone’s standard.

With a massive 10 year warranty and free returns on their 120 night satisfaction guarantee trial, you have nothing to lose giving them a shot and seeing what all of the Brunswick fuss is about.

Runner Up: Linenspa Innerspring Mattress

LINENSPA 6 Inch Innerspring Mattress

 

Proving that you don’t have to spend hundreds of dollars to get a comfortable and supportive innerspring mattress, the Linenspa Innerspring Mattress has managed to do it all with a much lower price tag.

This twin size mattress measures 75 x 39 inches and is 6 inches in height so it’s suitable to put into a bed frame or even lay on the floor if you don’t mind sleeping lower to the ground.

Linenspa makes other sizes in this style up to a California King, so you can choose the perfect one to suit your home.

The best thing about this mattress is the value for money and convenience it offers, especially in the setup and shipping stages.

It comes in a compressed and rolled to save shipping weight and when you break open the cover it will unfold and start to decompress right before your eyes.

Your kids can even help you set it up and it’s comfortable enough to sleep with it straight on the floor without the need for a box spring or frame underneath.

The Linenspa Innerspring Mattress uses heavy gauge tempered steel coils which give the mattress a firm feel, but it’s still very comfortable considering the low price.

There’s a quilted fabric covering it and an additional memory foam layer but you can still feel the springs if you try hard enough so keep that in mind.

This would make a great guest mattress or something for small children but an adult may find it uncomfortable for a permanent bed solution.

Other notable features of the Linenspa Innerspring Mattress are the fire-resistant barrier that keeps loved ones safe and the long warranty that covers it for defects.

The materials used to make it include polyester, fiber, and polyurethane foam, so for the price, it’s surprisingly well made.

Measuring around 6” thick it’s quite thin and easy to fit wherever you need to, and it weighs around 24lbs in case you need to move it to another room.

To purchase this mattress for your kids’ room or a guest bedroom, you’ll only have to pay around $80 on Amazon, which includes free shipping to your home.

With a massive 10 year manufacturer’s warranty and plenty of happy reviewers, this is the best value for money innerspring mattress we could find and one that will assist in many comfortable nights of sleep for your family.

Alternatives: Innofia Innerspring Mattress

Inofia Twin XL Mattress

 

The Innofia Innerspring Mattress is an ideal choice for a permanent bedding solution. This twin XL mattress comes in other sizes, but as their most popular at 12” thick and 80” long this one ticks all of the boxes.

The Innofia mattress is a hybrid design that features individually encased coils, a double layer of soft knitted fabrics and memory foam, and a non-slip fabric cover that keeps the mattress together.

Thanks to the memory foam encasing the coils, this is a very comfortable mattress that still responds to how you’re lying and is perfect for people with back and neck issues.

The memory foam works with the coils so that you’ll feel minimal disturbance even if the person sharing your bed moves around, but it still gives you responsive support.

It’s ideal for those who crave quiet sleeping conditions and usually get easily disturbed by someone else in the bed, but don’t want to give up their soft mattress.

Because the mattress is compressed before sending, it can be dangerous to open and some reviewers even got hurt in the process.

There are warnings from the manufacturer about how it pops open when you open the plastic wrapping, but people seemed shocked at just how hard and fast this happened.

This is one feature that needs to be rectified by Innofia, even if it means getting rid of the convenient compressed packaging.

This mattress weighs around 51lbs so it’s pretty heavy and the measurements are 80 x 39 x 12 inches. In terms of thickness is bigger than most we’ve reviewed and according to Innofia, it’s a medium in terms of firmness.

The memory foam and quilted fabric layers help to give it its softness while the springs inside create a hard and responsive layer for you to get total body support.

You can purchase the Innofia Innerspring Mattress through Amazon for around $220 so it’s a little on the expensive side just for an XL twin, but that cost also includes its free shipping.

This innerspring comes with a 10 year warranty and hundreds of happy reviews, so if you’re in the market for a responsive innerspring mattress to make your permanent bed this one will make you very happy.

Olee Sleep Innerspring Mattress

Olee Sleep 10 Inch Cool I-Gel Foam Top Innerspring Mattress

 

A mattress needs to be more than just a comfortable place to lay, and the Olee Sleep Innerspring Mattress can do this for you. This mattress features a cool I-Gel foam that cools down the mattress and improves airflow so it’s like having an air conditioner in your bedroom as well.

Measuring 75 x 54 x 10″ for the full size mattress, there’s ample room to spread out each night and reap the benefits of this unique cooling system.

What makes this mattress so unique is the different layers used to make it comfortable and cool. There are 7.5 inches of heat-treated coils combined with layers of memory foam, DuraFoam, and high-density foam, just to name a few.

The result is a seriously soft mattress that still feels supportive, and it’s a good choice for anyone who likes their mattress to be more luxurious than firm.

The first negative of this mattress has to do with the position of the springs inside and the fact that you can feel them when you’re sitting or laying on the edge of the mattress.

Unless you’re used to sleeping directly in the middle of the bed and not sharing with anyone, then this will become obvious quickly.

Another downside is that those in colder climates will need to add extra layers for warmth before going to bed. This mattress features a hollow fiber inner that means the air goes straight through.

If it’s hot this can be a godsend, and if it’s cold, then you’ll probably be freezing through the night.

There are still plenty of great features in the Olee Sleep Innerspring Mattress including its CertiPUR-US certification that means it’s free from harmful emissions and the Okeo-Tex stamp of approval for quality.

The Olee Innerspring features a soft gel memory foam that you can feel as soon as you lay down and it allows the mattress to cradle your entire body for maximum support. This is a great choice for the best innerspring mattress for side sleepers for this very reason.

Olee Sleep offers a 10 year warranty on this and you can purchase an additional 10 year protection plan through Amazon if you choose.

The best price for the mattress is also on Amazon, so you can expect to pay around $190 with free postage if you ship the current sale they’re having.

Overall, the Olee Sleep Innerspring Mattress features many layers of softness, but as it’s not made for all types of weather it won’t be everyone’s perfect fit.

Sleep Master Innerspring Mattress

Sleep Master 8

 

The Sleep Master Innerspring Mattress is made for people who want a firm night’s sleep and With four layers including a jacquard polyester cover, quilted fabric, comfort foam, and springs, it’s expertly made and you’ll be able to feel the difference.

The springs are 7.5 inch iCoil pocketed springs which gives it its firmness and it features a tight top so that any movement on the mattress is virtually undetectable.

What customers like best about this mattress is the high quality which is surprising for the mid range price tag. The mattress has been expertly desgined with multiple layers of coils and foams, and there’s no possible way you can feel the springs when you’re on top of it.

It has a lengthy warranty but just by looking at it you can see that it would last a lifetime if you took good care of it, so the value for money can’t be beaten.

According to customers, this mattress is extremely firm and you probably won’t appreciate the feel of it unless that’s your specific preference when it comes to sleep.

Although it’s been marketed by Sleep Master as a firm mattress, you might be surprised when you lay on it and realize just how firm they mean. You can’t feel the springs which is a bonus, but it’s also not soft and cushiony, so make sure you’re aware of this before you buy.

This is a solid mattress, weighing over 60lbs, so make sure when you get it you know exactly where it’s going. Once it’s opened, you should give it 48 hours to get to its true shape, allowing it some time to plush up a bit.

The Sleep Master Innerspring Mattress is made with active charcoal to eliminate odors and green tea extract to keep it clean, so you have peace of mind that natural materials are at work.

Sleep Master offers a 10-year warranty on all of their mattresses and you can expect to pay around $190 for the full size innerspring on Amazon which includes shipping directly to your door.

They have other sizes available to suit your home’s needs but it’s recommended to feel the firmness before you purchase any more. If you’re someone who craves a solid sleeping base then this will be the best coil mattress that money can buy.

The FAQ About Innerspring Mattresses

Touching Springs on Mattress

Choosing an innerspring mattress is a big decision and one that will ultimately affect the quality of your sleep.

If you’re wondering where to start or what it is that makes spring mattresses different to other types, we’ve answered some of the most commonly asked questions about them to help you make the right choice.

Are Spring Mattresses Good?

The best spring mattress should have quality coils as well as other layers of foam or cushioning for support.

All mattresses vary in quality and there are both good and bad mattresses in all types, with the more expensive ones usually being better quality.

Generally though, a spring mattress is considered a good choice and has different features that affect the way they feel and the benefits they offer.

Is Spring Mattress Better Than Foam Mattress?

There’s no singular type of mattress better than others as it depends on personal preference, but most modern spring mattresses incorporate foam into their construction as well.

The springs keep the mattress firm and supportive and the foam makes them softer, so choosing a hybrid is popular for many people.

Does Spring Mattress Cause Back Pain?

Older models of spring mattresses were sometimes associated with back pain because of their firm feel.

These days, spring mattresses are made with memory foam or other layers of foam and cushioning to prevent this from happening.

A good quality spring mattress should provide total body support to your spine so their main purpose is to reduce back pain.

Do You Need A Boxspring With An Innerspring Mattress?

Mattress Boxspring

A mattress box spring used to be required for innerspring mattresses to give them support and allow the coils to work correctly.

Newer models have this support built in so there’s no need to use one if you don’t want to.

These days, people sleep with their innerspring mattresses on the floor or a basic bed frame and can get the same benefits as they would with a box spring.

Do More Coils Mean Better Mattress?

The notion that more coils equate to a better mattress is an incorrect one, as it’s more about coil size and placement. The more coils added to a mattress the smaller they’ll need to be, which can end up feeling uncomfortable, so don’t just choose the one with the highest count.

Even with poor quality coils, the feeling can be adjusted with things like the choice of upholstery used to cover them or how many additional layers of foam or protection are on top. Therefore, coil count shouldn’t be the only thing that a buyer looks for when choosing a quality mattress.

How Long Does An Innerspring Mattress Last?

All mattresses are made differently and this includes the quality of materials and craftsmanship that can impact how long they last. An innerspring mattress usually lasts up to 10 years before the strength of the springs starts to weaken, and at this point they’ll no longer be supportive.

Modern hybrid mattresses that use both springs and foam can help with longevity but again it depends on the quality of the mattress materials and its construction.

Check the manufacturer’s warranty when you purchase an innerspring mattress to get a good idea of how long it’s been built to last.

Why Do Innerspring Mattresses Sag?

One of the most common complaints about innerspring mattresses is that they start to sag or dip in certain areas where someone has been laying, making them no longer comfortable or supportive.

The most common reason for this sag is because the springs inside have weakened and no longer offer the strength or support they used to.

To prevent a mattress from sagging, careful consideration must be made when you purchase one to choose a mattress with coils that are strong, individually encased, carefully placed, and of the correct size. Choosing a mattress with more springs will not prevent it from sagging alone, and this is a common misconception people have.

Full Body Support With One Simple Fix

The innerspring mattress is certainly not a new invention, but it’s one that continues to improve over time.

These days, a standard innerspring mattress is usually a hybrid that combines the wonders of memory foams and gels with the strength of coils, and the result is a bed that’s both luxurious and supportive.

Investing in a quality mattress is usually something that we put off, but judging by the countless happy reviews that these have received it’s a purchase that will pay off in no time at all.

Provided you shop for a mattress that suits your personal needs, whether that be extra firm or cushiony and soft, you’ll reap the rewards of a good night’s sleep on your mental and physical health.

These are our recommendations for the best innerspring mattresses on the market today, and it’s easy to see you don’t have to spend a fortune to get a quality one.

A good mattress will last you many years and considering most of them have a warranty period of at least 10 years, it’s a purchase you won’t have to think about again for a long time